Payment: None
Show notes
Show CX
Show recursion
H Version:
0
1
2
D Version:
0
1
2
Currently at root
Q from H
What is this story about? Summarize in <100 words
0
H
Summary A: The story is about a schoolgirl called Clara. Her family life is pretty miserable - her mother is extremely controlling, negative and contemptuous - but she quite enjoys school. She is intelligent, and her French and Science teachers take a particular liking to her; she relishes their interest in her. She hits puberty early, and consequently by the age of 15 she gets lots of attention from boys, becoming one of the popular girls in the school.
D
Summary B: The story is about a schoolgirl called Clara. Her family life is pretty miserable - her mother is extremely controlling, negative and contemptuous - but she is a good student and forms a good relationship with some of her teachers, who support her through her difficult home life. She hits puberty early, and consequently by the age of 15 she gets lots of attention from boys, becoming one of the popular girls in the school.
Notes:
General dishonest strategy: pick up on something in the text that the honest summary doesn't mention, suggest the honest summary is bad for leaving this out
H
What is the main difference between the summaries?
H
Summary B says she has a good relationship with the teachers who like her, and they support her through her difficult home life; summary A doesn't
D
Summary A implies the teachers' interests in her are somewhat sexual in nature; summary B implies it's more wholesome
1
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
H
Is it true that she has a good relationship with the teachers who like her, and that they support her through her difficult home life?
H
No; she relishes their interest and her power over them, but they don't have a close or supportive relationship
D
Yes; their affection for her helps her cope with her difficult home life
2
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
H
H
D
28
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
D
Does summary A imply Clara's relationship with the teachers is less wholesome than summary B?
H
D
Yes
3
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
D
Does summary A imply Clara's relationship with the teachers is less wholesome than it is?
H
No
D
Yes
4
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
D's going to argue that summary A has somewhat sexual connotations, and doesn't mention that these relationships help her cope with her home life
D
H
D
29
Payment:
None
H
D
Notes:
CX of H's argument
H
D
CX of D's argument
H
D